SAI independence must not depend on the Government’s goodwill

The Centre for Civic Education (CCE) considers the demands of employees of the State Audit Institution (SAI), who are launching a general strike, to be justified, particularly given that the competent authorities failed to respond adequately even after the warning strike.

CCE recalls that the SAI strike committee is demanding the implementation of conclusions adopted by the Parliament of Montenegro, under which the Government was tasked with “providing funds, through the rationalisation of budget expenditure and from the current budget reserve, to improve the material position of state auditors employed by the SAI, as well as undertaking activities aimed at urgently securing adequate office premises”.

The role of the SAI, as a key oversight mechanism for the spending of public funds and the management of public finances, is particularly important in a system in which few institutions are prepared to clearly point to irregularities and, where their findings warrant it, issue a negative opinion on the work of audited entities. The SAI has done so in numerous cases in recent years, confirming the importance of its independence and professional integrity.

Within its capacities, CCE provides full support to the work of the SAI. This year alone, CCE submitted eight well-founded audit initiatives to the SAI, following analyses that indicated the need for independent scrutiny of the operations of RTCG, the Montenegrin Academy of Sciences and Arts (CANU), the University of Montenegro (UoM), the Ministry of Defence, the Parliament of Montenegro, the Police Directorate, the Judo Federation of Montenegro, and the Ministry of Sports and Youth.

An institution tasked with protecting public funds cannot safeguard its independence without adequate working conditions. This includes a stable material position for employees, commensurate with the complexity and responsibility of their work, as well as basic office conditions, which the SAI has lacked since its establishment in 2004. Instead of treating the SAI as an ally in establishing more responsible management of public finances, the Government, and particularly the Ministry of Finance, has in recent years reduced the funding for its work that had previously been approved by Parliament’s Committee on Economy, Finance and Budget.

Such an approach also runs counter to the European Commission’s recommendations in the 2025 Report on Montenegro, which point to the need to ensure greater financial and operational independence of the SAI in practice, strengthen its still insufficient staffing capacities, and improve the implementation of SAI recommendations across the public administration. It is additionally concerning that, on two occasions last year, the Ministry of Finance refused to approve the SAI rulebook regulating auditors’ salaries, raising the issue of inappropriate influence by the executive branch on the functional independence of an institution whose very role is to oversee that same executive branch.

The Law on the State Audit Institution stipulates that funding for its work is provided through the state budget, while the SAI Senate proposes its draft budget and submits it to the competent parliamentary working body and to the Government. It is highly problematic when the executive branch, through budgetary decisions, restricts the operating space of an institution responsible for scrutinising how that same executive manages public funds. Such an approach may also create a perception that critical audit findings carry a price in the form of the executive’s treatment of SAI funding, which in itself undermines trust in the system of institutional oversight. If the Government genuinely seeks alignment with European standards, it must apply them even when they strengthen institutions that scrutinise its work.

CCE therefore believes that the financial independence of the SAI should be regulated systemically, including consideration of a model that would guarantee by law a minimum level of funding for its work, thereby limiting the scope for discretionary budgetary pressure by the executive branch. The independence of the SAI must not depend on the goodwill of the Government it is tasked with overseeing. Otherwise, independence remains a legal declaration rather than a genuine guarantee of the protection of public funds.

Snežana Kaluđerović, Senior Legal Adviser