Criteria met, impartiality unchecked – UCG owes answers in the case of Ivana Radovanović

Centre for Civic Education (CCE) points to serious questions raised by the case of Dr Ivana Radovanović, Assistant Professor at the Faculty of Fine Arts (FLU), whom the Senate of the University of Montenegro (UCG) did not elect to the title of Associate Professor on 4 June 2026, although all three reviewers recommended her election, the Scientific Committee established that she met the prescribed requirements and criteria, and the Senate itself confirmed this in the reasoning of its decision.

Of the 21 Senate members who voted, eight supported her election, while 13 abstained, without a single vote against. The Senate concluded that meeting the criteria constituted a “necessary, but not sufficient condition” and that the “required level of academic support” had not been achieved. The FLU Council also did not dispute Radovanović’s professional and artistic references or professional achievements, but assessed that the decision could not be based solely on compliance with the prescribed criteria and the evaluation of scientific, artistic and professional references, but also on the “overall professional engagement” within the academic community, including academic cooperation, institutional development, professional communication and relations within the academic community, while the public airing of disputes between the candidate and the institution was also cited as a relevant circumstance.

This is precisely why CCE asks: if UCG decided to assess Radovanović on such a broad basis, did it examine with equal attention the impartiality of those who decided on her election? Was the fact that persons whose conduct is the subject of court proceedings initiated by Radovanović against UCG and FLU also participated in deciding on her election disclosed as a circumstance that could raise the issue of a possible conflict of interest, who assessed such a circumstance, and was the need for their recusal from decision-making considered? The “broader picture” cannot apply only to the candidate and cease where the question of a possible conflict of interest of those deciding on her professional future begins.

At the beginning of 2026, CCE submitted an initiative to UCG to improve the regulatory framework in the area of conflicts of interest, proposing mandatory reporting of relevant relationships, institutional assessment of possible conflicts of interest, and a procedure for recusal from decision-making. To date, we have received no response to that initiative, while the new Statute adopted in June 2026 also failed to establish a comprehensive preventive mechanism for such situations.

The case of Ivana Radovanović is also addressed in CCE’s publication “When the Rules Remain Silent on Conflict of Interest – Regulatory Gaps at UCG, Comparative Analysis and Recommendations for Academic Integrity”. The new statutory provision, according to which a person may be re-elected to the same title no more than once, while a subsequent failure to be elected to a higher title may also lead to termination of employment, adds a particular dimension. The decision on election to a higher academic title is therefore no longer merely a matter of academic advancement, but may directly determine the continuation of a professional career at UCG.

A particular question concerns Irena Orović, Chair of the UCG Scientific Committee, which on 1 June positively assessed Radovanović’s references and established that she met the requirements for election. According to information provided to CCE, three days later, as a member of the Senate, Orović abstained in the final vote. A positive opinion of the Scientific Committee does not oblige a Senate member to support the candidate, but the fact that Radovanović was not elected without a single vote against, with 13 abstentions, justifies the question of what determined such an outcome. If Orović abstained, it is reasonable to expect her to explain which additional circumstances, beyond the positively assessed references and fulfilled criteria, were relevant to her position and according to which criteria they were evaluated.

This question gains additional institutional weight after the UCG Senate proposed Irena Orović for Rector of UCG on 5 October. A person proposed for the highest executive position at UCG bears a heightened responsibility to contribute to dispelling doubts regarding the consistency, transparency and impartiality of academic decision-making.

Points alone do not confer a right to election to a higher academic title, but it is relevant that Radovanović had 1,519.79 points, of which 660.5 were obtained after her previous election, along with positive recommendations from all three reviewers. By comparison with some other elections at FLU, Adela Zejnilović had 514.55 points when elected to the title of Associate Professor, while Zdravko Delibašić had 703.95 points.

Also concerning is the information that the documentation Radovanović submitted to the Scientific Committee during the election procedure is no longer available and that she has not been granted renewed access to that documentation. UCG must therefore establish and explain where the documentation is located, who was responsible for its safekeeping, and why the candidate was not granted access to it. It is also relevant that in an earlier procedure concerning Radovanović, the Administrative Court had already annulled a UCG Senate decision due to the lack of adequate reasoning.

This case provides an illustrative insight into the work of UCG’s management, as it demonstrates that professional references and prescribed criteria are less important than the subjective views of those deciding on academic appointments, and that ignoring the importance of addressing conflicts of interest is already producing far-reaching negative consequences.

UCG’s autonomy does not mean that its decisions are beyond legal and institutional control, nor can it serve as a basis for avoiding responsibility for the manner in which they were made, and UCG owes the public answers to questions surrounding the Radovanović case.

Jovana Radulović, Programme Assistant